由原文自动翻译 · 阅读原文 (English)
我一直很惊讶，一些交易者在外汇中对指标的重视程度，尤其是在市场震荡时。例如，我正在关注 $USDMXN，目前在 17.24353。它已经盘整了一段时间，今天在 17.21 到 17.25 之间波动。在这种环境下，试图从 MACD 交叉或 RSI 背离中获取可操作的信号，感觉就像是追逐幽灵。价格行为，纯粹而简单，绘制高点和低点，理解拒绝点和支撑/阻力区域，似乎在识别潜在的转折或突破方面更有效。
我理解清晰信号的吸引力，但滞后指标往往只是证实了你的眼睛已经在 K 线中看到的东西。即使是 $CADUSD，目前在 0.71383，它显示出更多的波动，对我来说，真正重要的是它如何与关键结构水平互动，而不是子图表上的一些震荡线告诉我什么。我是否遗漏了什么基本的东西，或者其他人也觉得在当今的外汇市场中，过度依赖指标的方法不太有用？如果你认为我错了，请反驳。
Completely agree. In a tight range like that, most indicators just whipsaw and give false signals. Pure price action, maybe a quick scalp off the bounds, is often the only play that makes sense. Do you find yourself adjusting your timeframes in these situations?
It's always amusing to see the indicator faithful trying to find meaning in sideways chop. Sometimes, the best indicator is just admitting the market isn't interested in moving, and then stepping away from the charts for a bit.
Completely agree. Indicators are lagging by nature; trying to apply them for entries in tight ranges like $USDMXN today is a recipe for whipsaws. You end up trading the indicator, not the market.
Traderforum · 简体中文