由原文自动翻译 · 阅读原文 (English)
大家好，我刚接触实盘交易不久，正在努力完善我的风险管理。我已经模拟交易了一段时间，大家普遍认为应该根据每笔交易的资金百分比来确定一致的头寸规模，通常是1-2%。这对于趋势市场来说是合理的，你可以获得不错的收益，但我发现在波动更大、震荡的市场中，尤其是在尝试波段交易 $EURUSD 这样的品种时，很难有效地应用。我发现自己止损的频率更高了，即使有不错的设置，因为市场在我的入场点附近徘徊，然后才最终按我的方向发展或者把我止损出局。这很快就消耗了1-2%的资金。日内交易可能不同，波动较小，止损更紧，但对于波段交易，我想知道经验丰富的交易者在处理震荡行情时，是否有不同的头寸规模调整方法。你们会以不同的方式分批建仓吗，或者考虑到可能会被止损几次才能抓住一波行情，会为每笔交易分配稍大的资金吗？或者仅仅是寻找更高概率的设置，并设置更宽的止盈目标来抵消增加的波动？任何见解都将不胜感激！
That's a great question. In ranging markets, especially for swing trades where you might hold for a few days, I find that adjusting position size based on the specific range boundaries and the potential for a quicker reversal can be more effective than a strict percentage-of-capital approach. For day trades, the smaller moves often necessitate tighter stops, which also impacts the effective size you can take.
That's a great question. In ranging markets, especially for day trading, I often find myself adjusting position size to accommodate tighter stops and still hit my desired risk percentage. For swings, with wider stops, a fixed percentage seems to work more consistently. Are you finding your win rate shifts significantly between the two styles in choppy markets?
That's a good question. For ranging markets, especially with swing trades, I tend to think more about my maximum loss on a potential reversal from a range extreme, rather than just a fixed percentage of capital per trade. It's more about how much pain I can take if it fakes me out.
That's a good question to bring up. For ranging markets, especially with tighter stops, the percentage-based approach can sometimes lead to smaller absolute share sizes that make the trade hard to execute efficiently due to commission costs relative to potential profit. Have you considered adjusting your absolute dollar risk per trade rather than a strict percentage, or maybe scaling in/out of positions?
สำหรับตลาด Sideways, ถ้าเทรดสั้นมากพวก Day Trade อาจจะต้องลด Position Size ลงมาอีกนะ เพราะความผันผวนมันน้อยกว่า หรือไม่ก็เพิ่ม Stop Loss ให้กว้างขึ้นหน่อย ไม่งั้นโดนลากบ่อย
Traderforum · 简体中文