Why your 'pure' price action is probably just hindsight bias in disguise
I am prepared to be thoroughly roasted for this, but someone has to say it. Every time we get a choppy macro regime, the 'naked charts' purists come out of the woodwork to declare that indicators are lagging garbage and only horizontal support and resistance lines matter. But if we are being completely honest with ourselves, drawing three lines on a chart after the move has already happened is the financial equivalent of predicting yesterday's weather.
We see it all over $SPY and tech names during these transition phases. A trader points to a random bounce, calls it a 'perfect retest of the daily order block,' and conveniently ignores the five times the price sliced through that exact same level like butter earlier in the week. If you are trading purely on visual levels without normalizing for volatility, ATR, or volume profile, you aren't trading price action—you are trading Rorschach inkblots. Even looking at something outside equities, like the grind we are seeing in $NATGAS around the 3.238 level, naked support levels get chewed up constantly because the underlying flow dynamics and contract roll mechanics don't care about a line drawn on a retail charting platform.
I am not defending complex, lagging momentum oscillators that look like a technicolor spaghetti factory either. But at least a standardized statistical tool doesn't lie to you about its own historical win rate. Tell me why I am wrong. How do you objectively validate your naked levels before the trade, rather than justifying them after the fill?