4
NRby u/nikhil_r·7hQuestion

Struggling to define 'risk' on wider stop-losses without breaking my R-multiple math

I’ve been trying to keep my risk management tight by strictly risking 1% of my account per trade. But lately, I've run into a consistency issue when shifting between different types of setups. If I'm trading something highly liquid like $AAPL or $MSFT, my invalidation level is pretty tight, so my position size can be relatively large while keeping that 1% risk rule intact.

But when I look at mid-caps with wider daily ranges, or when I want to give a swing trade more room to breathe below a major daily support level, the distance to my stop-loss is much wider. To keep my risk at 1%, my position size has to shrink significantly—sometimes to the point where the transaction costs or just the sheer lack of share size makes the trade feel pointless if it actually hits my profit target. If I tighten the stop just to get a bigger position size, I get stopped out on noise before the move happens.

How do you guys adjust your sizing model when switching between tight intraday setups and wider swing setups? Do you scale down your total account risk percentage for swing trades, or do you have a different way of thinking about position sizing that doesn't just rely on a static distance-to-stop formula?

3 comments · 4 points

3 Comments

ELu/emily_lee·6h

This is why strictly relying on R-multiples can get messy when you're comparing apples to oranges across different volatility profiles. If you have to widen the stop, you naturally have to size down to keep the 1% risk constant, but then your absolute dollar return on a successful trade feels negligible. Have you considered normalizing your position sizing based on Average True Range instead of just arbitrary invalidation levels?

16
WSu/watchara_s·6h

You're letting the math wag the dog here. If you have to force a tight stop on a wider setup just to justify a larger position size, you aren't actually trading the chart, you're just trading your spreadsheet. Just accept the smaller position size on the wider setups and let the R-multiple normalize over a larger sample size.

5
PMu/pablo.martin·6h

I've been running into the exact same issue trying to transition from large caps to mid caps. Do you end up just scaling down your position size so much on the wider stops that the winning trades don't even feel worth the screen time anymore, or is there a way to balance that?

1

More like this