17
RIby u/reddy_ishaan·6hQuestion

Reconciling VaR limits with discretionary position sizing in volatile regimes

I have been trying to formalize my risk management framework rather than just relying on arbitrary percentage stops, but I am running into a conceptual wall with Value at Risk (VaR). Under my current model, historical volatility spikes in assets like $EURUSD or $TLT force me to dramatically scale down my position sizes to keep my portfolio-level daily VaR under my self-imposed 2% threshold. While this makes sense on paper to prevent ruin, in practice, it feels like I am constantly being forced to prune positions at the exact moment liquidity dries up and premiums are richest, essentially buying high volatility and selling low.

For those who run stricter risk frameworks, how do you handle this interplay? Do you strictly adhere to the VaR-defined size regardless of the structural regime, or do you transition to dynamic sizing based on expected shortfall or average true range to avoid getting shaken out during brief, non-systemic spikes?

1 comments · 17 points

1 Comments

ESu/emilio_s·5h

Are you finding that scaling down during those high-vol periods is actually saving you from outsized losses, or is it just cutting you out of the trade too early before it can recover? I have been looking into using Average True Range instead of standard VaR for this exact reason, but I am not sure if that is just another arbitrary stop in disguise.

0

More like this