Evaluating liquidity provider depth versus aggregate feeds for spot FX and cross-border settlement
We have been reviewing our primary brokerage setup for a small prop-trading desk, primarily focusing on $EURUSD, $GBPUSD, and some G10 crosses. Over the last two quarters, we've noticed a significant divergence in execution quality during thin liquidity windows—specifically the NY-Tokyo crossover. Our current prime-of-prime aggregator claims a '0.1 pip average spread,' but the actual realized slippage on limit-on-close orders above 5 lots has been degrading steadily.
I am trying to determine whether it is worth the administrative overhead to move from a retail-hybrid aggregator to a direct institutional prime broker with a dedicated LCG/ECN bridge. The onboarding and KYB process for corporate entities at the Tier-2 level is notoriously painful right now, often taking 6 to 8 weeks just to clear compliance. Before we commit the legal hours to that transition, I wanted to ask how others here evaluate true depth of book beyond the marketing PDF. Are you monitoring execution latencies and fill rates programmatically, and at what monthly volume threshold did the transition to a direct Prime broker actually start to yield a net positive on your bottom line after accounting for higher clearing fees?
We ran into the exact same issue during the crossover and realized our PoP aggregator was internalizing too much flow before sweeping. We switched to direct API feeds from two primary LPs for G10, and while the quoted spread looks wider, the fill ratio and slippage improved dramatically.