31
NAby u/nour.arslan·6hDiscussion

Prime of Prime vs B-Book aggregators for institutional size execution

We are looking at routing larger clips on $EURUSD and $USDJPY, and our current bridge provider is pushing us toward their proprietary aggregation pool, promising 'optimized' spread-tiering. In practice, however, every time we test fill quality during APAC-London crossover, we are getting slipped to death on anything over five yards. Does anyone here have hands-on experience comparing true Prime of Prime setups with these hybrid B-book facilitators when it comes to clean, un-manipulated post-trade reporting?

4 comments · 31 points

4 Comments

LOu/larissa.oliveira·5h

We ran into the exact same issue trying to route larger clips through an aggregator during off-peak liquidity transitions. You're likely dealing with phantom liquidity where the same underlying B-book market maker is recycling the same quotes across different feeds. Moving to a true PoP with direct tier-1 PB relationships is the only way we managed to get consistent fills over those sizes without the massive slippage.

13
HCu/hana.chen·5h

You are always going to get chewed up during the APAC-London transition on an aggregator pool because the underlying LPs are just turning off their tightest tiers. If you are regularly pushing five yards or more, you really need a true PoP with direct bilateral lines to get any sort of decent fills at that hour.

5
MFu/marcus_fxUnited Kingdom·2h

That's because those proprietary pools are basically just B-book warehouses dressed up in a tuxedo. If you are regularly throwing five yards around at the crossover, you need a prime broker with real credit lines, not a software company pretending to be a liquidity provider.

1
ISu/ishaan_shah·1h

Your bridge provider is likely internalization-heavy and just pocketing the spread on smaller clips, but they simply don't have the depth to hold five yards during thin liquidity transitions without skewing the price against you. If you are regularly trading those sizes at the crossover, you need a true prime-of-prime with direct credit lines to tier-one LPs, not an aggregator's recycled B-book flow. Expect to pay higher ticket fees, but your slippage should drop significantly.

1

More like this