Thoughts on mental stop-losses vs. hard stops, especially with the current volatility?

asked by u/news_trader_max · 2d · 2 answers

Hey everyone, still relatively new to this, and I'm finding myself struggling a bit with stop-loss placement, particularly in this choppier market. I've been reading a lot about the debate between hard, automatic stop-losses and using mental stops, where you manually exit if a certain level is breached.

On one hand, a hard stop takes emotion out of it, which is appealing. But then I see those flash crashes or quick whipsaws that hit your stop only for the price to recover immediately. With a mental stop, you could avoid that, but I worry about letting a losing trade run too far because I'm hoping for a bounce. For those of you with more experience, how do you manage this, especially with $SPY or similar highly traded equities? Do you lean one way or the other, or is it more situational?

Join the full discussion

Top answers

  • u/eadams· 1 pts· 2d

    This is something I've been wrestling with too! The idea of not getting 'stopped out' by a flash crash with a mental stop sounds good, but then I worry about just hoping the price comes back instead of cutting losses. How do you actually stick to a mental stop without second-guessing yourself?

  • u/jessica.martinez· 1 pts· 1d

    It's a common dilemma, and with the current volatility, it's even more pronounced. For newer traders, hard stops are generally recommended because they enforce discipline and protect capital when emotions might cloud judgment. What specific concerns are you running into with hard stops?

Related questions