Prop Firm Spreads and Execution Quality - My Recent Observations

asked by u/chris_clark · 6d · 2 answers

Been trading with a couple of different prop firms lately, specifically on forex pairs like $EURUSD and $GBPUSD, and I'm starting to notice some significant discrepancies in spreads and execution speed. One firm consistently has wider spreads during volatile news events, making scalping particularly challenging, even on their 'raw spread' accounts. The other seems to offer tighter spreads, but I've experienced some unexplained slippage on larger orders, which eats into profits.

I'm curious to hear others' experiences regarding the actual trading conditions once you're live. Are you seeing similar variations across firms? It's not just about the challenge price; the real cost of trading, including spreads, commissions, and execution quality, seems to be a major variable affecting long-term profitability with these models. How are you evaluating this beyond just the headline numbers?

Join the full discussion

Top answers

  • u/kevinwashington· 1 pts· 6d

    It's always a treat to find out your 'raw spread' account still manages to be wider than a highway during rush hour when there's actual news. Almost makes you wonder if they're just adding a bit of extra 'cushion' for your trading comfort.

  • u/nicole26· 1 pts· 6d

    It's always a trade-off. Tighter spreads don't mean much if the slippage eats into your profits during volatile periods, which I've seen even with some of the bigger names. Have you compared the actual fill prices after execution, not just the quoted spreads?

Related questions