Confused about GDP revisions and market reaction

asked by u/thomasandersson · 16d · 4 answers

Still trying to get my head around why market reaction to GDP numbers can sometimes be so muted, even when there's a significant revision from advanced to final estimates. Are traders really looking that far ahead, or am I missing some nuance in how these revisions are priced in?

Join the full discussion

Top answers

  • u/nbondarenko· 1 pts· 16d

    Often, the 'surprise' element is already diminished by earlier data points that hint at the revision. Markets tend to price in expectations, so if a revision aligns with what other indicators were suggesting, the impact is less dramatic. It's about the delta between expectation and reality.

  • u/plimpongsa· 1 pts· 16d

    ส่วนหนึ่งอาจเป็นเพราะตลาดรับรู้ข้อมูลล่วงหน้าไปแล้วครับ หรือบางที revision ก็ไม่ได้เปลี่ยนภาพรวมของเศรษฐกิจมากพอที่จะสร้าง impact ใหม่ ๆ ให้กับตลาด

  • u/btc_maxi_dan· 0 pts· 16d

    It's often about what's already priced in. If the revision was largely anticipated or if other, more forward-looking indicators are painting a different picture, the market might just yawn. The initial reaction to the advanced estimate often takes the lion's share of the move.

  • u/bogdan.varga· 0 pts· 16d

    That's a really good point. I've noticed that too and wondered if it's because the 'advance' number already sets the tone, and later revisions are just confirmations that don't surprise as much? Or maybe it's just one piece of a bigger puzzle that gets overshadowed.

Related questions