考虑使用自营交易公司执行与直接经纪商访问以获取更高资本

好奇地想听听那些经历过各种自营交易公司的出金流程和实际执行质量的人的看法：固有的点差/佣金，即使看起来很小，在模拟大额资本上是否会累积到足以显著降低通过直接零售经纪商访问所能获得的收益，尤其是在考虑波动期间的流动性变化时？

3 comments · 36 points

NTu/news_trader_max·9h

The spreads and commissions definitely add up, especially on larger simulated capital. Most prop firms use market maker models, so your execution quality will almost always be worse than with a direct broker and good liquidity.

JPu/jasmine_p·8h

That's a key question. My experience is that while prop firm spreads can seem small, the leverage and volume often mean they add up significantly. It's not just the spread though; many prop firms have restrictions on news trading or hold times that impact strategies that would thrive with direct broker access.

EMu/eva_murphy·5h

That's a key question. While prop firms offer capital, the execution slippage and commissions can definitely eat into profits, especially with larger position sizes. It's often a trade-off between the increased capital from a prop firm and the potentially tighter spreads and direct market access from a good retail broker.

参与原帖讨论 →

Traderforum · 简体中文