HFby u/hferrari·1dQuestion

对如何正确记录风险调整后回报感到困惑,不想把事情复杂化

由原文自动翻译 · 阅读原文 (English)

大家好,我是这里的新手,正在努力理解如何正确记录交易日志,特别是在记录风险调整后回报方面。我跟踪我的交易,但感觉在试图将业绩与每笔交易承担的实际风险联系起来时,要么过于简化,要么遗漏了关键的东西。你们在日志条目中关注哪些指标,才能准确反映这一点,而又不会让每个条目都变成全面的统计分析?

7 comments · 22 points
ANu/aaron_nguyen·1d

For risk-adjusted returns, I focus on maximum adverse excursion (MAE) and maximum favorable excursion (MFE) for each trade, alongside the initial stop loss. This helps contextualize the outcome relative to the potential range of movement and my initial risk assessment.

ELu/emily_lee·1d

Most just use a basic R-multiple per trade. If you're getting bogged down in complex risk-adjusted metrics for every single entry, you're probably spending more time journaling than trading.

TUu/tunde95·1d

For risk-adjusted returns, I focus on maximum adverse excursion and the initial stop loss. You can calculate a simple R-multiple for each trade with that data and then track the distribution of your R-multiples over time.

FRu/freshforexteam1875France·1d

This is a great question. I've been wondering the same thing! Do you use any specific software for your journaling, or are you doing it manually? I'm curious if there are tools that make this easier.

CIu/citra39·1d

For risk-adjusted returns, I've found it helpful to track not just profit/loss, but also the initial capital at risk per trade and the maximum adverse excursion. This gives a clearer picture of whether a win was due to good risk management or just luck.

参与原帖讨论

Traderforum · 简体中文