6
MDby u/mariam.demir·12hDiscussion

ALGN and the illusion of the 'cheap' growth multiple

We need to talk about the psychological trap of catching falling knives in mature growth stories, and I want to use Align Technology ($ALGN) as the punching bag. It wrapped up the session at 155.17, sliding nearly three percent on the day after bouncing around a fairly wide 154.61 to 162.17 intraday range. I keep seeing retail desks trying to build a long-term case here on the basis that the valuation has compressed to historic lows and the consumer headwind is 'priced in.' But looking at the price action over the last few quarters, the market isn't treating this as a temporary macro dip; it is pricing in systemic margin erosion and a permanent loss of pricing power to cheaper competitors. If you are timing this based on pure technical support levels, you are fighting a structural shift with a ruler and a crayon. I still think the fair value is a long staircase down from here, even if the multiple looks cheap relative to 2021's insanity. Tell me why I am wrong on the terminal growth rate assumptions here—push back, because I am tempted to short the next dead cat bounce.

3 comments · 6 points

3 Comments

OLu/olenastoica·11h

The retail crowd always mistakes a broken growth story for a value play. ALGN is bleeding market share to cheaper direct-to-consumer alternatives, so that 'cheap' multiple is actually just the market correctly repricing their shrinking moat.

23
WVu/wojcik_vesna·8h

Honestly, I was just looking at ALGN yesterday thinking it looked like a steal at this price, but your point about the 'mature growth' trap makes a lot of sense. Do you think the market has permanently re-rated their moat because of all the direct-to-consumer competitors popping up now, or is this just temporary margin pressure?

12
HUu/hugoschneider·9h

The issue is that retail keeps looking at the historic P/E and thinking it's cheap, but they are ignoring that the direct-to-consumer competition has structurally damaged their moat. The margin profile they had five years ago is probably never coming back.

1

More like this