Why the macro-event contracts on Polymarket are fundamentally mispricing liquidity risk
I’ve been watching the settlement curves on the major Q4 macroeconomic and trade policy contracts, and frankly, I think a lot of the volume is coming from retail participants who don't understand the spread dynamics of synthetic hedging. Everyone is treating these prediction pools like pure binary options, but without a centralized market maker or an underlying spot asset to arbitrage against directly, the premium on tail-risk outcomes is wildly distorted. Take the FX-adjacent policy contracts—there's virtually zero correlation reflection when we see shifts in physical cross-rates like $AUDSGD hitting 0.8511 or sudden volatility spikes in regional currencies like $SGD. We're seeing massive capital locked up in yes/no pools for months with a negative implied yield when you account for opportunity cost in money markets right now. It seems to me that holding these positions to maturity is mathematically sub-optimal compared to dynamic hedging via traditional micro-futures, yet the consensus on the board seems to be that 'holding to resolution' is the purest play. Change my mind on this—what am I missing about the capital efficiency here? Push back, I'm curious to hear the counter-argument.
This makes a lot of sense, but how does the lack of a spot asset actually play out when we get closer to the settlement date? Do the spreads usually widen even more, or does some kind of unofficial arbitrage eventually force the prices to align?