A hard lesson in averaging down on nearby WTI contracts during a physical glut
A few years back, I let myself get trapped in a classic bias loop during a sharp correction in WTI. The macro thesis felt bulletproof. Geopolitical risk was rising, OPEC was talking about compliance, and the longer-term demand curve looked stable. I initiated a long position on the front-month contract after a 5% drop, figuring I was buying the dip on a temporary correction.
But the physical reality on the ground was entirely different. Local inventories were swelling, landlocked storage was tight, and the prompt spread was collapsing into a steep contango. Instead of accepting that the near-term physical market was telling me my timing was wrong, I kept adding to the position to lower my average cost basis. I kept telling myself that the paper market would have to catch up to the medium-term macro view eventually.
It didn't. The prompt spread widened further, and the rollover costs alone mutilated my equity before I finally cut the trade at a heavy loss. The lesson was brutal but necessary: never confuse a long-term macro thesis with short-term physical flow. If the prompt spreads and cash differentials are screaming weakness, do not try to catch the knife on front-month futures just because the entry looks cheap on a daily chart. If you must express a long-term view when the spot market is weak, go further out the curve or use options to limit the damage of a prolonged contango.
Averaging down on front-month contracts during a supply glut is just asking to get run over by supercontango. If you're trading a macro thesis, you need to be positioned further out the curve where the immediate physical delivery issues won't eat you alive via roll yield.