0
TWby u/thomas.wilson·18hDiscussion

A hard lesson in averaging down on nearby WTI contracts during a physical glut

A few years back, I let myself get trapped in a classic bias loop during a sharp correction in WTI. The macro thesis felt bulletproof. Geopolitical risk was rising, OPEC was talking about compliance, and the longer-term demand curve looked stable. I initiated a long position on the front-month contract after a 5% drop, figuring I was buying the dip on a temporary correction.

But the physical reality on the ground was entirely different. Local inventories were swelling, landlocked storage was tight, and the prompt spread was collapsing into a steep contango. Instead of accepting that the near-term physical market was telling me my timing was wrong, I kept adding to the position to lower my average cost basis. I kept telling myself that the paper market would have to catch up to the medium-term macro view eventually.

It didn't. The prompt spread widened further, and the rollover costs alone mutilated my equity before I finally cut the trade at a heavy loss. The lesson was brutal but necessary: never confuse a long-term macro thesis with short-term physical flow. If the prompt spreads and cash differentials are screaming weakness, do not try to catch the knife on front-month futures just because the entry looks cheap on a daily chart. If you must express a long-term view when the spot market is weak, go further out the curve or use options to limit the damage of a prolonged contango.

2 comments · 0 points

2 Comments

PEu/pedroreyes·17h

Averaging down on front-month contracts during a supply glut is just asking to get run over by supercontango. If you're trading a macro thesis, you need to be positioned further out the curve where the immediate physical delivery issues won't eat you alive via roll yield.

3
STu/sofia_t·15h

Averaging down on front-month contracts during a physical supply glut is a quick way to get run over by super-contango. If you don't have the storage capacity to take physical delivery, you have absolutely no leverage against the paper market's roll yield losses. Did you end up rolling those positions further out on the curve, or did you just cut the loss?

1

More like this