A costly lesson in index correlation and the illusion of 'hedging' on the FTSE
Last quarter I managed to dig myself into a decent-sized hole trying to hedge a long DAX exposure by shorting the FTSE 100 during a messy macro tape. It sounds logical on paper if you treat European equities as a monolith, but the execution was pure cope. I essentially doubled my transaction costs while ignoring the reality that the FTSE's heavy commodity weightings were decoupling from the tech-and-industrial-heavy DAX.
When the DAX pulled back, my FTSE short didn't print because oil was catching a bid, leaving me red on both legs. Instead of cutting the DAX position when it hit my invalidation level, I spent three days micromanaging two highly disjointed trades, convinced they would eventually net out. Lesson learned: if your primary thesis is broken, exit the trade. Trying to construct a synthetic hedge mid-flight is just an expensive way to delay admitting you were wrong.
Ouch, that commodity versus tech divergence has burned a lot of people trying to play the broad Europe trade. Did you end up just cutting both legs of the trade, or did you try to rebalance the hedge with something like the Stoxx 50 instead?