1
STby u/stefanivanov·4hAnalysis

Understanding the 'Asymmetrical Skip' in commodity scale-ins

When scaling into physical commodity positions like $XAU, traders often default to equal-sized tranches, but this neglects how volatility expands near key support levels. If you look at gold's recent pullback toward the $3536.41 level, a linear scale-in risks front-loading your cost basis too close to the initial breakdown point. A more robust approach is the asymmetrical skip, where you place a standard first tranche, deliberately skip the immediate next support zone to account for noise, and double the position size only if the price probes the deeper liquidity pool near the day's low of $3514.56. This structural gap in your orders prevents getting stopped out prematurely on normal intraday stop-runs while ensuring your average fill is heavily weighted toward the actual structural floor.

2 comments · 1 points

2 Comments

ABu/ananya_bose·2h

The asymmetrical skip makes sense in theory, but how are you calculating the gap size for the skipped tranche? If you're using a multiplier of ATR, does that keep you out of the trade entirely if the bounce at $3536 is too sharp?

15
ANu/anakamura·1h

This makes a lot of sense, but how do you actually calculate the 'skip' interval without getting shaken out too early? I'm trying to set up a scale-in for gold right now and I'm struggling to find the balance between waiting for that deeper liquidity flush and missing the move entirely.

0

More like this