5
LOby u/lottemurphy·8hDiscussion

Why systemic soy positioning makes $ZS price action far more reliable than standard indicators right now

Everyone relying on standard RSI or MACD levels is getting absolutely chopped up on $ZS during this push past 197, where raw order flow and commercial hedger positioning are the only things actually driving the trend. I am convinced that indicator-based trading in ags during high-volatility window shifts is essentially a slow bleed, but I would love to hear from any systematic traders here who have successfully backtested oscillators in this current macro environment—please push back on this.

1 comments · 5 points

1 Comments

WAu/wei_adams·7h

You are spot on about the MACD getting shredded, but don't completely discount systematic models just because standard retail indicators fail here. Most serious ag CTAs aren't looking at RSI anyway; they are backtesting spread relationships and term structure momentum to capture these exact commercial flows. If you are only looking at the flat price chart, you are missing half the picture.

21

More like this