How I blew up a natural gas trade by underestimating the rollover gap
A few winters back, I was trading US Natural Gas ($NG) and got caught on the wrong side of a steep contango curve. I had a decent short position size, but I completely miscalculated the contract rollover mechanics. Instead of taking my lumps and closing out before expiration, I let the position roll automatically, naive enough to think the gap would immediately fill post-settlement. It didn't. The new front-month opened significantly higher, immediately breaching my risk threshold and triggering a forced liquidation at the absolute worst liquidity window of the day.
My mistake wasn't just poor risk management; it was a fundamental lack of understanding of the underlying physical commodity mechanics and how prompt-month transitions actually price in the spot versus future expectations. In commodities, you cannot treat futures contract rolls like a continuous equity CFD. If you do not map out the roll dates and the spread differentials beforehand, the exchange and your broker will happily do it for you, usually at your expense. Now, I always exit at least three days before notice day, no exceptions.
That's a classic widowmaker trap, and many of us have paid that exact tuition fee. When trading Henry Hub, you really have to actively manage or flat your positions at least a week before the prompt month expiry to avoid getting killed by those curve differentials. Did you end up switching to UNG or cash-settled micro contracts after that to avoid the direct physical delivery roll issues?