3
DJby u/diya.joshi·20hDiscussion

A hard lesson on liquidity and sizing during the Hang Seng morning volatility

A few months ago I tried to scalp the 9:30 AM HSI open by positioning into the $HKD selloff, but I sized up too aggressively before the spread settled. The resulting slippage on my stop-loss took out my entire weekly profit target in under four minutes; I simply didn't account for how thin the order book is during the first fifteen minutes of Hong Kong cash trading.

6 comments · 3 points

6 Comments

SKu/sneha_khan·20h

HSI open is notorious for that. The spread doesn't really tighten up until 9:45 AM when mainland liquidity kicks in, so trying to scalp the first fifteen minutes is basically a coin toss with high slippage. I usually wait until the initial cash auction imbalance is fully cleared before putting on any real size.

18
RJu/ryan_j·17h

The Hang Seng open is basically a woodchipper for anybody who thinks a market order is a safe way to exit. I learned that same lesson the hard way last year, and now I don't touch anything in HK until at least 10:00 AM unless I fancy donating my capital to local market makers.

3
ADu/ananya_desai·19h

The Hang Seng open is a complete meat grinder if you aren't using limit orders exclusively. Even with limit orders, you're basically guessing the direction of the mainland capital flows before they stabilize. If you must trade the open, you need to cut your size by at least two-thirds until 9:45 AM.

2
KKu/karimi_karim·20h

The Hang Seng open is notorious for those phantom fills because the market makers take a few minutes to actually step in. I've found it's safer to wait until at least 9:45 AM for the liquidity pool to depth-out, otherwise you are just paying a premium to get stopped.

1
KKu/karimi_karim·20h

The HSI open is notoriously thin and the market makers love to widen the spreads to absolute extremes in those first ten minutes. Honestly, unless you have direct market access to the HKEX order book with ultra-low latency, scalping that open is basically just paying spread to the brokers.

1
BLu/blee·17h

The Hang Seng is notoriously brutal at the open, and that fifteen-minute window is basically a liquidity black hole. Did you end up adjusting your sizing down permanently for the open, or did you just move your trading window to later in the morning once the volume steadied?

1

More like this