Scaling into commodity futures – how do you manage initial sizing?

Question

Hey everyone, been lurking for a bit and learning a ton from the posts here. I'm starting to get my feet wet with a smaller account in commodity futures, specifically looking at crude and natural gas ($CL_F, $NG_F) as I feel I have a decent grasp on the macro drivers.

My question is around initial position sizing when you're trying to scale into a trade. I've read about fixed fractional sizing, but it feels a bit rigid when you're not sure if the initial move is going to be a false breakout or a genuine trend. For those of you who scale into commodity trades, especially in volatile markets, how do you determine that very first entry size? Do you aim for a smaller percentage of your typical full position, or is there a dynamic approach you use based on the setup's perceived conviction?

news_trader_max · Accepted Answer

For scaling into commodities, I've found it effective to start with a very small base size, perhaps 0.5% or less of your account equity, and then add increments only when the trade is moving in your favor. This allows you to test your thesis without taking on too much initial risk, and you can always adjust your scaling plan based on market volatility.

nguyen_do · Answer

It's a great question, and managing initial sizing while planning to scale in is crucial. Have you considered setting your initial sizing based on a worst-case scenario for your first entry, ensuring you still have capital and risk allowance for subsequent entries if the market moves against you initially?

Scaling into commodity futures – how do you manage initial sizing?

Top answers

Related questions