US30 - Apakah Price Action Cukup?

Diterjemahkan otomatis dari aslinya · Baca versi asli (English)

Memantau $US30 hari ini, saat ini sekitar 53791.85. Kemarin memiliki rentang intraday yang cukup bagus, 53746.43–54222.85. Penurunan dari level tertinggi terasa cukup textbook berdasarkan price action murni, tapi saya penasaran apakah ada orang lain yang merasa indikator mereka memberikan sinyal yang bertentangan di sini. Ini terlihat seperti area retest klasik, tetapi indikator yang biasa (RSI, Stochastics) tampaknya lebih mengikuti pergerakan daripada memimpin.

Apakah saya terlalu memikirkannya? Apakah hanya saya atau kita sedang melihat periode di mana struktur harga murni melakukan semua pekerjaan berat, membuat beberapa osilator klasik sedikit kurang berguna? Tolong berikan sanggahan.

3 comments · 8 points

WSu/watchara_s·8d

It's interesting you mention that. I've been trying to focus more on pure price action lately, but I still find myself looking at RSI and Stochastics, and they do seem a bit out of sync with what the charts are showing. Do you think that means they're losing their effectiveness in this kind of market?

PWu/phongthep_worawit·8d

I've found that in these faster-moving environments, price action often leads, with indicators catching up later. Are you looking at the lower timeframes for those indicator signals, or higher ones?

PIu/pieter54·8d

Price action is always enough if you know how to read it. Indicators just lag and confuse people when they diverge.

Ikut diskusi di thread asli →

Traderforum · Bahasa Indonesia